19 Comments
User's avatar
Laura Moore | Strange Clarity's avatar

This was a fantastic interview, entertaining but also chock-full of practical nuggets. Thanks!

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

Thank you! I'm glad you found it useful =]

Expand full comment
Alizah Holstein's avatar

Informative and generous, as other commenters have noted. Thank you! And as an author with a PhD in medieval history, I have really enjoyed reading Irina Dumitrescu's numerous contributions to the NYRB and elsewhere. As a field, medieval history has suffered deep cuts in the past 15 years, so it's especially great to see it representing in the culture at large through her essays and reviews.

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

That is sad! I love the medieval period: it seems so fruitful, and it feels like it hasn't been picked over quite as much as the other periods--there's still so much that's unstudied and even untranslated.

Expand full comment
Irina Dumitrescu's avatar

Thank you so much for this generous note, Alizah. I do try to represent the field as best I can.

Expand full comment
William Lambert's avatar

I love reading Irina on any subject, so hearing this advice from her specifically is great. Thanks for the interview Naomi!

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

Thank you! She's really great--a very honest, careful writer.

Expand full comment
Henry Begler's avatar

nice one, it's a real public service putting this info out there!

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

I was thinking especially of you!

Expand full comment
Sara Fredman's avatar

@Irina Dumitrescu is the best!

Expand full comment
Derek Neal's avatar

Great conversation. I like the anecdote about how trying to get rejected led to getting something published. Now when I have an idea for a pitch I’m going to think of it as “trying to get rejected” rather than “trying to get something accepted.”

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

It does seem like creating that connection to the editor is the most important thing, and rejection can form that connection just as much as an acceptance can

Expand full comment
Michael Patrick Brady's avatar

Do people know about the list of editors Adam Morgan maintains at the NBCC? It’s not perfect/always up to date but it’s a good starting point. https://www.bookcritics.org/publications/

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

Yes this is a great resource! I was aware of this but I always forget about it. Maybe I'll write up a post with all these resources about pitching.

Expand full comment
Autumn Widdoes's avatar

I can’t thank you enough for the generosity of this essay and interview. It’s so helpful. I briefly met Boris at the LARB publishing workshop. From the short exchange I found him to be very knowledgeable and open to different ideas and approaches. I wonder how many editors have that same skill set and which publications they are working at.

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

Boris was great! I am sure he's moved on to better things (I see his name all over the place as a poet and russian-language translator), but it's sad not to have him there anymore. With editors, it's really hard to know who's good and who's not--and even when you figure it out, they inevitably change jobs or leave the industry and you have to start all over!

Expand full comment
The Ivy Exile's avatar

An enormously helpful conversation that jibes with my pitching experience. (Not that I have any plans to pitch the NYT or NYRB anytime soon...)

Expand full comment
Naomi Kanakia's avatar

I know, me neither. Best to be out of it. But lots of the kids are still aiming for that =]

Expand full comment
Andrea Stoeckel's avatar

How to review books for the NYT- don't

Expand full comment