Reading another pair of books that are exactly the same

This time it's a pair of books about groups of girlfriends tryna make it in their twenties: Jennifer Knoll's Girls in White Dresses and J Courtney Sullivan's Commencement. I still can't tell whether these are good books or not. They're ridiculously compelling and emotional, but they're also stacked high with cliches. For instance, in Commencement (the b…